24 2" x 2" squares cut out and glued onto 12 wood tiles. The game actually works out pretty well for what it is (some randomness, but current game state is perfect information). It's lightweight.
The end product will be these same 2" x 2" wooden squares, but with nicely printed stickers from Stickermule.
I wonder if I can get a solo play version so I can send it over to Every Night is Game night. Hm!